Joe Pyfer has three losses against three opponents on his MMA record. For a list of Pyfer's best fights, refer to "Best fights of Joe Pyfer".
On February 10, 2024 Joe Pyfer faced off against Jack Hermansson in a middleweight bout at age 27. He was coming in with a record of 12-3 (9), and Hermansson was 35 years old and with a record of 23-8 (17). Pyfer lost the fight via 5-round unanimous decision.
On August 11, 2020 Joe Pyfer faced off against Dustin Stoltzfus in a middleweight bout at age 23. He was coming in with a record of 7-2 (5), and Stoltzfus was 28 years old and with a record of 12-1 (6). Pyfer lost the fight via 1st-round TKO.
On November 23, 2019 Joe Pyfer met Jhonoven Pati in a middleweight (ROC Championship) title defense fight. Pyfer was 23 years old and with a record of 6-1 (4). Pyfer lost the fight via 2nd-round submission and lost the title.
