Billy Evangelista has three losses against three opponents on his MMA record. For a list of Evangelista's best fights, refer to "Best fights of Billy Evangelista".
On June 20, 2014 Billy Evangelista faced off against Felipe Fogolin in a welterweight bout at age 33. He was coming in with a record of 13-3 (5). Evangelista lost the fight via 1st-round submission.
On December 17, 2011 Billy Evangelista faced off against K. J. Noons at age 31. He was coming in with a record of 11-2 (4), and Noons was 29 years old and with a record of 10-4 (8). Evangelista lost the fight via 3-round unanimous decision.
On March 5, 2011 Billy Evangelista faced off against Jorge Masvidal at age 30. He was coming in with a record of 11-1 (4), and Masvidal was 26 years old and with a record of 20-6 (11). Evangelista lost the fight via 3-round unanimous decision.