Here is a list of Mathis Jr.'s best fights. For a list of Mathis Jr.'s losses, refer to "Buster Mathis Jr. Losses".
On February 5, 1994 Buster Mathis Jr. faced off against Tyrell Biggs at age 23. He was coming in with a record of 13-0 (3), and Biggs was 33 years old and with a record of 27-7 (18). Mathis Jr. won the fight via 12-round unanimous decision.