Here is a list of Culcay's best fights. For a list of Culcay's losses, refer to "Jack Culcay Losses".
On December 5, 2015 Jack Culcay faced off against Dennis Hogan in a super-welterweight bout at age 30. He was coming in with a record of 21-1 (10), and Hogan was 30 years old and with a record of 22-0-1 (7). Culcay won the fight via 12-round unanimous decision.
On August 28, 2020 Jack Culcay faced off against Abass Baraou in a super-welterweight bout at age 34. He was coming in with a record of 29-4 (13), and Baraou was 25 years old and with a record of 9-0 (6). Culcay won the fight via 12-round split decision.