Here is a list of Garcia's best fights. For a list of Garcia's losses, refer to "Elijah Garcia Losses".
On September 30, 2023 Elijah Garcia faced off against José Armando Resendiz in a middleweight bout at age 20. He was coming in with a record of 16-0 (13), and Resendiz was 24 years old and with a record of 14-1 (10). Garcia stopped José Armando Resendiz via TKO.
On March 22, 2025 Elijah Garcia faced off against Terrell Gausha in a middleweight bout at age 21. He was coming in with a record of 17-1 (13), and Gausha was 37 years old and with a record of 24-4-1 (12). Garcia won the fight via 10-round split decision.